2003

The Fourth Circuit tells us:

Generally speaking, chemical crabgrass control products are most effective when applied to “pre-emergent” crabgrass . . . the products are also effective on early “post-emergent” crabgrass but are ineffective when applied to mature crabgrass plants . . .   Scotts [plaintiff] contends that the Vigoro [defendant] package misleads consumers into believing

Suppose you grow grapes for a living and you believe that your grapes are better than everybody else’s grapes.  In fact, you spend a lot of money branding your grapes so that people will choose your grapes, not just anybody’s grapes.

Now here comes the state telling you that you have to contribute money to some